Dragonfly Supply
Cooking · Gear We Love

The Best Pie Irons for Camping (and What to Make in Them)

A pie iron — you might know it as a mountain pie or pudgy pie maker — is two cast-iron plates on long handles that toast a sealed sandwich or pie right over the fire. Here's why it might be the most fun thing in your camp box: the kids make their own dinner. They pick the fillings, they work the fire (with a hand), and they're weirdly proud of the slightly-burnt sandwich they made themselves. It's cheap, nearly indestructible, and it covers breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert with the same tool.

The Best Pie Irons for Camping (and What to Make in Them)

Our picks

Best overall

Rome Square Cast Iron Pie Iron (#1705)

The iconic original, made in the USA by Rome since 1964. The square head fits standard sliced bread with no wasted corners, which makes it our default pick for most families.

View on amazon
Best for a crew

Rome Double Pie Iron (#1605)

Cooks two sandwiches at once, so you are not running a one-at-a-time line for a pack of hungry kids. The one to get if everybody wants theirs now.

View on amazon
The classic round

Rome Round Pie Iron (#1805)

Makes the classic 4-inch round mountain pie. You will trim the corners off your bread, but if the round shape is the one you grew up with, this is it.

View on amazon

How to choose

Why a pie iron is the best $25 you'll spend

Most camp gear is something you use to feed the kids. A pie iron flips that — it's the thing the kids use to feed themselves, which is the whole magic. They butter the bread, choose what goes inside, and hold it over the coals (with supervision), and somehow a toasted cheese sandwich they made beats anything off the camp stove. It's cast iron, so it's basically indestructible, and "mountain pie night" becomes the meal everyone remembers. For the same long-handle-over-the-coals fun at snack time, see our campfire popcorn popper.

How to use one

It couldn't be simpler:

  • Butter the outside of two slices of bread (the sides that touch the iron).
  • Lay one slice butter-side-down in the iron, add your fillings, top with the second slice butter-side-up.
  • Close it, latch it, and trim any bread hanging over the edge so it seals.
  • Toast in the coals, not the flames — a few minutes a side, peeking until it's golden. Flames char the outside while the middle stays cold.

The first one is always the test one. After that everybody dials in their timing.

Square or round, single or double?

  • Square fits standard sliced bread with no wasted corners — our default, and what most families want.
  • Round makes the classic mountain-pie shape, but you'll trim the corners off your bread.
  • Single is one sandwich at a time; double does two at once, which matters a lot when three kids all want theirs right now.

Breakfast, lunch, dinner, dessert

This is where it earns its space — one tool, every meal:

  • Breakfast: scrambled eggs with cheese and ham, or an egg-dipped slice with cinnamon for campfire French toast.
  • Lunch: the classic grilled cheese, ham and cheese, or a pizza pocket (sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni).
  • Dinner: spoon in last night's camp chili with cheese, or taco filling for a crispy hand pie.
  • Dessert: the original mountain pie — buttered bread and cherry or apple filling — or a s'mores version with chocolate and marshmallow.

For a full meal-by-meal guide — including pie iron pizza — see our easy pie iron recipes hub. It's a natural across all of it: breakfast, lunch, and dinner.

Seasoning and care

Pie irons are cast iron, so treat them like the rest of your cast iron. Season before the first use (there's often a wax coating to burn off over the fire first), butter the bread every time so nothing sticks, and wipe them clean rather than scrubbing. Done right, one pie iron outlasts the kids who learned to cook on it.

A few honest tips

  • Don't overfill — an overstuffed iron won't close or seal, and the filling oozes into the fire.
  • Coals, not flames. Every burnt-outside-raw-inside mountain pie comes from impatience over open flame.
  • Let it cool a moment before opening near little hands; the filling is molten.

Common questions

What is a pie iron?
A pie iron (also called a mountain pie or pudgy pie maker) is two hinged cast-iron plates on long handles. You put a filled sandwich between them and toast it sealed over the campfire — great for everything from grilled cheese to fruit pies.
How do you use a pie iron?
Butter the outside of two slices of bread, put one butter-side-down in the iron, add fillings, top with the second slice butter-side-up, close and latch it, and toast in the coals a few minutes per side until golden. Cook over coals, not open flames.
Should I get a square or round pie iron?
Square is more practical — it fits standard sliced bread with no wasted corners. Round makes the traditional mountain-pie shape but means trimming your bread. For most families, square is the better buy.
Do you have to season a pie iron?
Yes — it's cast iron. Burn off any factory wax coating over the fire, then season it like a skillet. Butter the bread each time you cook and wipe it clean afterward, and it'll stay seasoned for years.
What can you cook in a pie iron?
Far more than dessert pies: grilled cheese and ham-and-cheese for lunch, eggs or French toast for breakfast, chili or taco-filling hand pies for dinner, and classic fruit or s'mores pies for dessert. One tool covers every meal.

Dragonfly Supply is reader-supported. When you buy through links on our site, we may earn an affiliate commission — at no extra cost to you. We only recommend gear we'd actually pack.